---

Questrade - Empowering you to take control of your financial future. Join the journey!

---

What is the difference between fixed and floating spreads?

---

Fixed Spreads vs. Floating Spreads: Understanding the Core Difference for Traders

When you're wading into the world of trading, one of the early concepts you'll encounter is the "spread." It's essentially the difference between the buy (ask) price and the sell (bid) price of an asset. This seemingly small number is crucial for understanding your potential trading costs and profitability. But not all spreads are created equal. You'll come across two main types: fixed spreads and floating spreads.

So, what's the deal? Let's break down the difference between these two fundamental spread mechanisms.

Fixed Spreads: Predictability at a Premium

As the name suggests, a fixed spread means that the difference between the bid and ask prices remains consistent, regardless of market conditions. When you open a trade, the spread you see is the spread you get, and it stays that way for the duration of your trade or until you close it.

Think of it like this: Imagine a store that always sells apples for $1 and buys them back for $0.90, no matter how many people are buying or selling apples. The difference is always $0.10.

Key Characteristics of Fixed Spreads:

• Predictability: The biggest advantage is the certainty it offers. You know exactly how much it will cost to open and close a trade, making it easier to calculate your potential profit or loss.
• Stable Costs: This predictability translates to stable trading costs, which can be particularly appealing for certain trading strategies.
• Less Volatility: Fixed spreads are typically offered by brokers who operate as market makers, meaning they take the other side of your trades. They control the prices and absorb the risk, allowing them to maintain a stable spread.
• Potential for Wider Spreads: While predictable, fixed spreads can sometimes be wider than the average floating spread during normal market conditions. This is the price you pay for that certainty.
• Limited by Market Conditions: In highly volatile markets, a fixed spread broker might widen their spreads temporarily to manage their risk, but this is usually communicated and less frequent than with floating spreads.

Who might prefer fixed spreads?
​

• Beginner Traders: The simplicity and predictability can reduce confusion and anxiety.
• Scalpers and Day Traders: Traders who execute a high volume of trades and rely on small, consistent profits often benefit from knowing their exact costs for each trade.
• Traders with Fixed Profit Targets: If you aim for a specific profit point, knowing your exact entry and exit costs is paramount.

Floating Spreads: The Dynamic Dance of the Market

Floating spreads, also known as variable or dynamic spreads, are directly influenced by the real-time supply and demand of the underlying asset in the broader market. This means the difference between the bid and ask prices can widen or narrow constantly.
Think of it like this: Imagine an auction where the price of an item fluctuates constantly based on how many people are bidding and how urgently they want it. The "spread" of what the seller is willing to accept and what the highest bidder is willing to pay can change by the second.

Key Characteristics of Floating Spreads:

• Market Driven: The spread reflects the true liquidity and volatility of the market at any given moment.
• Tighter Spreads in Normal Conditions: During periods of high liquidity and low volatility, floating spreads can be significantly tighter than fixed spreads, leading to lower trading costs.
• Wider Spreads in Volatile Conditions: Conversely, during periods of high volatility (e.g., major news events, economic announcements), floating spreads can widen considerably. This is the broker passing on increased market risk.
• Requires More Attention: Traders need to be more aware of market conditions as spreads can change rapidly, impacting their trading decisions and costs.
• Often Offered by ECN/STP Brokers: Brokers that route your trades directly to liquidity providers (like banks and other institutions) typically offer floating spreads.

Who might prefer floating spreads?
​

• Experienced Traders: Those comfortable with market dynamics and the potential for fluctuating costs.
• Swing and Position Traders: Traders who hold positions for longer periods might benefit from the historically tighter spreads in calmer markets.
• Traders Seeking Best Execution: The goal is to get the best possible price, and floating spreads aim to reflect true market prices.

The Key Takeaway: It's About Your Trading Style

The "better" option between fixed and floating spreads ultimately depends on your individual trading strategy, risk tolerance, and preferences.
​

• For beginners or those prioritizing certainty: Fixed spreads offer peace of mind and predictable costs.
• For experienced traders seeking efficiency and market reflection: Floating spreads can offer tighter costs in normal conditions and a more accurate representation of market liquidity.

As you gain more experience, you'll likely develop a preference based on how you approach the markets. It's always a good idea to understand how your chosen broker implements their spread system and to experiment with different account types to see what best suits your trading journey.

---