IFC Markets
Questrade - Empowering you to take control of your financial future. Join the journey!

What does "tracking error" mean in the context of ETFs? ​​

Tracking error in the context of ETFs refers to the difference between the performance of the ETF and the performance of its underlying benchmark index. Ideally, an ETF should closely match the returns of the index it tracks, but various factors can cause deviations. Tracking error is typically measured as the standard deviation of the difference in returns between the ETF and its benchmark over a specified period.

How Tracking Error is Calculated

Tracking error can be calculated by taking the difference between the daily (or periodic) returns of the ETF and its benchmark, then calculating the standard deviation of these differences over time.
A low tracking error indicates the ETF is closely following its index, while a high tracking error shows more significant deviation.

Causes of Tracking Error

  1. Management Fees and Expenses: ETFs have expense ratios that are deducted from the fund’s returns. This difference in returns due to fees often causes a small tracking error, as the ETF returns will be slightly less than the index.
  2. Cash Holdings: When an ETF holds a small amount of cash (for example, from dividends or when awaiting reinvestment), this can create a small deviation from the index, which is typically fully invested.
  3. Dividend Timing: ETFs may not reinvest dividends as quickly as the index would assume. If an index includes dividends immediately while the ETF must wait to distribute or reinvest, this delay can cause minor tracking error.
  4. Rebalancing and Sampling:
    • Rebalancing Costs: Some ETFs need to rebalance to maintain alignment with their index, incurring trading costs and potential deviations.
    • Sampling: Some ETFs use sampling rather than full replication of an index (especially in cases of large or illiquid indices), which can cause deviations in performance.
  5. Currency Effects: If an ETF holds international assets, currency fluctuations can impact returns differently from a U.S.-based index, causing tracking error.
  6. Market Volatility: Volatile markets can make it more challenging for ETFs to replicate an index exactly, often resulting in higher tracking error.
  7. Tax Treatment: Tax events and different tax treatments can lead to small differences in performance relative to the index.

Why Tracking Error Matters

  • For Investors: A low tracking error is generally preferred by investors who want returns that closely match the index. High tracking error can suggest inefficiencies, additional costs, or an inability to properly replicate the index.
  • Indicator of Efficiency: Tracking error provides insight into the ETF’s efficiency and the manager’s effectiveness in minimizing costs and maintaining alignment with the index.

Tracking Difference vs. Tracking Error

It’s important to distinguish tracking error from tracking difference:
  • Tracking Difference is simply the difference in annual returns between the ETF and the index.
  • Tracking Error measures the variability of this difference over time.
​
A consistent tracking difference due to fees (e.g., -0.10% annually) can result in a low tracking error, while a fluctuating tracking difference leads to a high tracking error.

Summary
​
Tracking error reflects how well an ETF mirrors its index, accounting for fees, dividend timing, market conditions, and other factors. Lower tracking error indicates closer alignment with the index, making it an essential metric for investors assessing an ETF’s reliability in providing the index’s intended exposure.
Forexmart
InstaForex