What are synthetic ETFs, and how are they taxed?

Questrade - Empowering you to take control of your financial future. Join the journey!

What are synthetic ETFs, and how are they taxed?

A synthetic ETF is an exchange-traded fund that uses derivatives (such as swaps) rather than directly holding underlying assets to replicate an index’s performance. Instead of physically owning stocks or bonds, synthetic ETFs enter into a total return swap agreement with a counterparty (usually a bank) to get the returns of an index.

Key Difference:

Traditional (Physical) ETFs directly hold the assets (e.g., an S&P 500 ETF owns S&P 500 stocks).
Synthetic ETFs use swaps or other financial contracts to replicate the index’s performance without actually owning the assets.

Why Use Synthetic ETFs?

Better Replication – Avoids tracking errors, especially for hard-to-access markets (e.g., emerging markets, commodities).
Lower Costs – Fewer trading fees since the ETF doesn’t physically buy/sell securities.
Tax Efficiency (In Some Countries) – Depending on tax laws, synthetic ETFs may avoid withholding taxes on dividends.
Risks:

Counterparty Risk – If the swap provider (e.g., a bank) defaults, investors could suffer losses.
Regulation & Complexity – Some regions impose stricter rules on synthetic ETFs due to transparency concerns.

How Are Synthetic ETFs Taxed?

Tax treatment depends on the country, ETF structure, and investor location. Here’s a breakdown of key tax implications:

1. Dividend Taxation (Potential Tax Benefit)

Since synthetic ETFs don’t hold physical stocks, they do not directly receive dividends.
However, the swap contract may include a dividend adjustment that replicates dividend payments.
In some jurisdictions (e.g., parts of Europe), this can help reduce foreign withholding taxes on dividends.

Example:

A physical S&P 500 ETF might be subject to 30% U.S. withholding tax on dividends.
A synthetic S&P 500 ETF could avoid this tax by using swaps that replicate total returns without directly receiving dividends.

2. Capital Gains Tax (Varies by Country)

In many countries, synthetic ETFs are taxed similarly to regular ETFs—investors pay capital gains tax when they sell shares.
In some jurisdictions (e.g., France, Germany, and the UK), synthetic ETFs may qualify for favorable capital gains tax treatment if structured as funds domiciled in tax-friendly locations (e.g., Ireland, Luxembourg).

U.S. Investors Beware:

The U.S. treats synthetic ETFs as Passive Foreign Investment Companies (PFICs), which are subject to punitive tax rates and strict reporting rules.
This makes synthetic ETFs unattractive for U.S. investors unless held in a tax-advantaged account where PFIC rules don’t apply.

3. Tax-Advantaged Accounts (IRAs, ISAs, SIPPs, etc.)

If held in a tax-advantaged account (e.g., IRA, 401(k), UK ISA, or European PEA), tax treatment differs:
- No immediate capital gains tax.
- Dividend tax efficiency may not matter in tax-deferred accounts.

Best Strategy:

If synthetic ETFs offer tax advantages (e.g., avoiding foreign withholding tax), they can be beneficial in taxable accounts.
If they don't offer tax advantages, holding them in a tax-advantaged account (IRA, pension, etc.) can help defer any tax impact.

Key Takeaways

Synthetic ETFs use swaps instead of holding assets, which can improve tax efficiency.
May avoid foreign dividend withholding tax, making them attractive in some jurisdictions.
Capital gains tax treatment varies by country—some favor synthetic ETFs.
U.S. investors should avoid synthetic ETFs due to PFIC tax rules.
Best for investors in Europe/Asia seeking tax efficiency, especially in taxable accounts.