IFC Markets
Questrade - Empowering you to take control of your financial future. Join the journey!

What is Insider Trading, and why is it illegal?​

​​​​​​Insider Trading refers to the buying or selling of a publicly traded company’s Stock or other securities (such as Bonds or Options) by individuals who have access to non-public, material information about the company. It can be either legal or illegal depending on when the insider makes the trade.

Legal vs. Illegal Insider Trading
​
  1. Legal Insider Trading:
    • Insiders, such as company executives, directors, or employees, can legally trade the company’s stock as long as they follow specific regulations and report their trades to the appropriate regulatory authorities.
    • Insiders are required to file their trades with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) (or equivalent regulatory bodies in other countries), often using Form 4. This information must be publicly disclosed, ensuring transparency.
    • These trades usually occur during "open windows", which are designated periods when insiders are allowed to trade without violating any laws.
  2. Illegal Insider Trading:
    • Illegal insider trading occurs when someone buys or sells stocks based on non-public, material information about the company. This type of trading violates securities laws because it gives the insider an unfair advantage over regular investors who do not have access to this information.
    • Material information refers to any information that could impact a company's stock price, such as earnings reports, mergers, acquisitions, spinoffs, or the development of new products. If disclosed, this information could influence an investor's decision to buy, hold, or sell a stock.

Why Insider Trading Is Illegal
​
  1. Unfair Market Advantage:
    • Insider trading is illegal because it gives individuals with access to confidential information an unfair advantage over the general public. This undermines the integrity of financial markets by creating an unequal playing field. Investors who do not have access to the same information are at a significant disadvantage.
  2. Breach of Fiduciary Duty:
    • Insiders, such as company executives and employees, have a fiduciary duty to act in the best interest of the company and its shareholders. Trading on non-public information violates this duty because it prioritizes personal gain over the interests of the broader market and shareholders.
  3. Market Confidence:
    • Illegal insider trading erodes investor confidence in the fairness of the stock market. If investors believe that markets are manipulated or rigged by insiders, they may lose trust in the financial system, leading to less participation and reduced market liquidity.
  4. Price Manipulation:
    • Insider trading can result in distorted stock prices, as the trades made based on non-public information may not reflect the company’s actual value. This leads to market inefficiency, where stock prices do not fully represent the true value of the underlying company.

Examples of Illegal Insider Trading
​
  • Corporate Insiders: A company’s CEO learns that the company will be acquired at a premium price and buys large amounts of the company's stock before the information becomes public.
  • Tipping: An executive shares non-public information with a friend or relative, who then trades the stock based on this tip. Both the insider who shared the information and the person who traded based on it can be charged with insider trading.
  • Non-Employees: Even individuals who are not company employees, such as lawyers, consultants, or journalists, can be guilty of insider trading if they trade based on non-public information they acquired in the course of their work.

Consequences of Insider Trading
​
  1. Civil and Criminal Penalties:
    • Violators of insider trading laws can face severe civil and criminal penalties. In the U.S., the SEC enforces insider trading laws and may impose fines and injunctions. The Department of Justice (DOJ) can bring criminal charges, which may result in jail time.
    • Fines: Individuals caught engaging in insider trading can face substantial monetary fines. These fines can be as high as three times the amount of profit gained or losses avoided due to the illegal trades.
    • Imprisonment: Those convicted of insider trading may face prison sentences, depending on the severity of the offense. In high-profile cases, sentences can extend to several years.
  2. Reputation Damage:
    • Individuals and companies involved in insider trading face significant reputational damage. Executives and companies found guilty of insider trading can lose public trust and damage their brand image, which can hurt business performance.
  3. Company Impact:
    • Insider trading scandals can result in shareholder lawsuits, financial penalties for the company, and a decline in the company’s stock price due to loss of investor confidence.

High-Profile Insider Trading Cases
​
  1. Martha Stewart:
    • In 2001, lifestyle guru Martha Stewart was convicted of insider trading after selling shares of a biotech company, ImClone, based on non-public information that its drug application would be rejected by the FDA. Stewart avoided significant financial losses by selling her shares, and she was sentenced to prison for her role in the illegal trade.
  2. Raj Rajaratnam (Galleon Group):
    • Raj Rajaratnam, the founder of the Galleon Group hedge fund, was convicted in 2011 of orchestrating one of the largest insider trading cases in U.S. history. He used non-public information from various corporate insiders to make trades, generating millions of dollars in illegal profits. Rajaratnam was sentenced to 11 years in prison.

Preventing Insider Trading

To ensure fair markets, regulatory agencies like the SEC closely monitor trading activities and take enforcement actions against illegal trades. Companies also take preventive measures to avoid insider trading by implementing insider trading policies, including:
  1. Trading Windows: Establishing specific periods (open trading windows) during which insiders are allowed to buy or sell stock.
  2. Blackout Periods: Prohibiting trading during sensitive periods, such as before earnings releases or major announcements.
  3. Mandatory Reporting: Requiring insiders to report their trades to regulatory bodies to ensure transparency.

Conclusion

​Insider trading is illegal because it undermines market fairness, breaches trust, and can lead to significant financial and legal consequences for those involved. By enforcing strict insider trading laws, regulators seek to maintain investor confidence in the stock market and ensure that no one benefits unfairly from non-public information. Legal insider trading, when done transparently, is permissible and provides insights into how company insiders view their company's prospects.
Forexmart
InstaForex