Questrade - Empowering you to take control of your financial future. Join the journey!

---

How does market-making work in Algorithmic Trading?

---

​​​What is Market Making?

At its core, market making is the process of providing liquidity to a market. A market maker (traditionally a person, but increasingly an algorithm) simultaneously quotes both a buy price (the "bid") and a sell price (the "ask") for an asset. They stand ready to buy at the bid and sell at the ask. The difference between the bid and ask is called the "spread," and this is where the market maker aims to profit.

The Market Maker's Role

• Providing Liquidity: Market makers ensure that there are always buyers and sellers available. This makes it easier for others to trade assets, as they don't have to wait for someone to match their order.
• Narrowing the Spread: Competition among market makers helps to narrow the bid-ask spread, which lowers transaction costs for everyone trading.
• Price Discovery: By constantly adjusting their bids and asks in response to order flow and market information, market makers contribute to the process of price discovery, helping to establish a fair market value for assets.
• Order Flow Management: They absorb temporary imbalances in buy and sell orders, preventing large price swings.

Algorithmic Market Making

Algorithmic (or automated) market making uses computer programs to perform the tasks of a traditional market maker. These algorithms are designed to:

1. Monitor Market Data: Continuously receive and analyze real-time market data such as:
   • Price Levels: Current bid and ask prices on different exchanges or across various liquidity providers.
   • Order Book Depth: The number of shares/contracts offered at each price level on the bid and ask sides.
   • Trade Volume: The rate and size of recent trades.
   • Market Sentiment: News, social media feeds, and other data that might indicate the overall market mood.
   • Related Asset Prices: Prices of similar assets, derivatives (options, futures), or assets in correlated markets.
2. Determine Fair Value: Use models to estimate the "fair" or "intrinsic" value of the asset. This can involve:
   • Statistical Models: Time series analysis, regression, and other statistical techniques.
   • Order Book Imbalance: Analyzing the relative strength of bids vs. asks to predict short-term price movements.
   • Inventory Management: Keeping track of the assets the market maker is holding, and adjusting prices to manage that inventory.
   • Event-Driven Models: Reacting to news releases, earnings reports, or other specific events that affect asset value.
3. Quote Generation: Based on the fair value estimate and a desired profit margin, the algorithm calculates the bid and ask prices. This calculation is influenced by:
   • Risk Aversion: How much risk the market maker is willing to take (e.g., holding a large inventory if the price moves against them).
   • Inventory Levels: If the market maker has a large inventory of the asset, they might lower the ask price to encourage sales.
   • Competition: The bids and asks of other market makers.
   • Order Book Depth: How deep is the order book on either side.
4. Order Placement & Management: The algorithm automatically places bid and ask orders into the market, managing them based on:
   • Order Type: Limit orders (to buy at the bid or sell at the ask), market orders (to execute immediately), or more complex order types.
   • Order Size: The quantity of shares/contracts to offer at each price level.
   • Order Refresh Rate: How frequently the algorithm updates its bids and asks (milliseconds or even microseconds are common in high-frequency trading).
   • Cancellation: If market conditions change rapidly, the algorithm may cancel outstanding orders to avoid adverse selection.
   • Execution Monitoring: Tracking which orders get filled and adjusting the trading strategy accordingly.
5. Risk Management: Algorithmic market makers need to manage several types of risk:
   • Inventory Risk: The risk that the value of their inventory will decline.
   • Adverse Selection: The risk of trading with informed traders who have superior knowledge of the asset's value.
   • Model Risk: The risk that the algorithm's fair value estimate is inaccurate.
   • Operational Risk: Risks associated with the technology and infrastructure supporting the trading system.
   • Regulatory Risk: Changes in market regulations or exchange rules

Key Advantages of Algorithmic Market Making

• Speed: Algorithms can react to market changes much faster than humans.
• Consistency: Algorithms apply the same rules and logic consistently, free from emotions or biases.
• Scalability: One algorithm can manage multiple assets or markets simultaneously.
• Efficiency: Lower transaction costs and tighter spreads due to automation and competition.
• 24/7 Availability: Can operate continuously, even when human traders are unavailable.

Challenges of Algorithmic Market Making

• Complexity: Developing and maintaining effective algorithms requires expertise in finance, mathematics, and computer science.
• Data Dependency: The performance of the algorithm depends on the quality and availability of market data.
• Competition: The market-making landscape is highly competitive, with many sophisticated algorithms vying for the same opportunities.
• Risk Management: Managing the risks associated with algorithmic trading is crucial to avoid large losses.
• "Flash Crashes" and Malfunctions: Potential for algorithms to malfunction or contribute to rapid market declines. Robust risk controls and kill switches are essential.
• Regulatory Scrutiny: Market regulators are increasingly focused on algorithmic trading and its potential impact on market stability.

Example Scenario

Imagine an algorithmic market maker trading Apple (AAPL) stock.

1. Data Ingestion: The algorithm receives real-time data from multiple exchanges showing the current best bid at $170.00 and the best ask at $170.05. It also sees that the order book has substantial depth on both sides.
2. Fair Value Estimation: The algorithm's model estimates that the fair value of AAPL is $170.02 based on factors like earnings reports, analyst ratings, and overall market sentiment.
3. Quote Generation: Considering its inventory levels, risk aversion, and the competitive landscape, the algorithm decides to offer a bid of $170.01 and an ask of $170.03. This provides a narrower spread than the current best quotes.
4. Order Placement: The algorithm automatically places a limit order to buy AAPL at $170.01 and a limit order to sell AAPL at $170.03.
5. Order Execution: If a buyer hits the market maker's ask price of $170.03, the algorithm sells shares of AAPL and earns a profit of $0.02 per share (minus exchange fees). If a seller hits the market maker's bid price of $170.01, the algorithm buys shares of AAPL.
6. Continuous Adjustment: The algorithm continuously monitors the market and adjusts its bids and asks based on changing conditions. If the stock price starts to rise rapidly, the algorithm might increase its bid and ask prices to maintain its desired spread and profit margin.

In summary, algorithmic market making is a sophisticated and complex process that uses computer programs to provide liquidity, narrow spreads, and contribute to price discovery. It offers significant advantages in terms of speed, efficiency, and scalability, but also presents challenges in terms of development, risk management, and regulatory compliance.

---