---

Questrade - Empowering you to take control of your financial future. Join the journey!

---

What is the difference between ECN, STP, and market-maker brokers?

---

Decoding Forex Brokers: ECN vs. STP vs. Market Maker – Which is Right for You?

When you first step into the world of Forex Trading, the technical jargon can be overwhelming. You’ll hear terms like "pip," "leverage," and "margin" constantly. But one of the most critical decisions you will make before placing a single trade is choosing the type of broker you want to work with.

Not all brokers are created equal. They differ in how they execute your trades, how they make their money, and whether their interests align with yours.

In this post, we’ll break down the three main types of brokers: Market Makers, STP, and ECN, so you can decide which one fits your trading style.

1. Market Makers (Dealing Desk)

Market Makers are often referred to as "Dealing Desk" (DD) brokers. As the name suggests, they literally "make the market" for their clients.

How it works:
When you want to buy a currency pair, a Market Maker doesn’t look for an outside seller. Instead, they take the other side of your trade. If you buy, they sell to you. If you sell, they buy from you. They set the prices themselves (usually mirroring the global market) and provide the liquidity.

The Pros:

• Fixed Spreads: You often know exactly what the cost of a trade will be, as spreads stay constant even during volatile news events.
• Low Entry Barrier: They often allow very small deposits and offer high leverage, making them popular with beginners.
• User-Friendly: Their platforms are usually simpler and more intuitive.

The Cons:

• Conflict of Interest: Since the broker is taking the opposite side of your trade, they technically profit when you lose.
• Requotes: If the market is moving fast, the broker might not let you enter at the price you clicked, "requoting" you a different price.

2. STP (Straight Through Processing)

STP brokers are "No Dealing Desk" (NDD) brokers. They act as a bridge between you and the real market.

How it works:
When you place a trade with an STP broker, they send it directly (straight through) to their liquidity providers—usually large banks or hedge funds. The broker doesn't take the other side of your trade; they simply find the best available price from their pool of providers.

The Pros:

• No Requotes: Because trades are executed instantly at the best available market price.
• Lower Conflict of Interest: The broker makes money by adding a small mark-up to the spread, meaning they want you to keep trading (and winning) so they can keep earning fees.
• Better Prices: You often get better bid/ask prices than with a Market Maker because the broker is shopping around multiple providers for you.

The Cons:

• Variable Spreads: Spreads can widen significantly during major news announcements or periods of low liquidity.

3. ECN (Electronic Communications Network)

ECN brokers are the "gold standard" for professional and high-volume traders. Like STP, they are No Dealing Desk brokers, but they go a step further.

How it works:
An ECN broker provides a digital hub where all participants (banks, hedge funds, and individual traders) trade against each other. You are seeing the "raw" market prices. Instead of making money on the spread, ECN brokers usually charge a fixed commission per trade.

The Pros:

• Tightest Spreads: It is common to see 0.0 pip spreads on major pairs like EUR/USD during peak hours.
• Transparency: You can see the "Depth of Market" (Level II pricing), showing you how many orders are waiting at what prices.
• Anonymity: Your trades are entered into a massive pool without any human intervention or bias.

The Cons:

• Commission Costs: While the spread is low, you have to pay a commission on every trade, which can add up for small-scale traders.
• Higher Minimums: ECN accounts often require a larger initial deposit.

Which one should you choose?

The right broker depends entirely on your strategy:

1. Choose a Market Maker if: You are a beginner with a small amount of capital (e.g., $100) and you want a simple, predictable environment.
2. Choose an STP Broker if: You want a fair middle ground with no requotes and don't want to worry about calculating commissions on every trade.
3. Choose an ECN Broker if: You are a scalper (making many trades for small profits), a high-volume trader, or someone who demands the most transparent and lowest-cost pricing available.

Final Thought

Regardless of the model you choose, always ensure your broker is regulated by a reputable authority (like the FCA, ASIC, or NFA). Execution style is important, but the safety of your funds is the ultimate priority.

​Happy trading!

---